Want to Invest in Property?

Let us help you make the right decisions for the best results.

Beware the Two-tier Property Market

By Jarrod McCabe

Melbourne’s spring property market is proving challenging times for buyers and sellers alike. There are still people looking to buy and others wanting to sell, but the two sides aren’t coming together as readily as we’d normally expect at this time of year.

Yet the market isn’t behaving the same way everywhere. Through conversations with agents and others in the property industry, we’re hearing signs of something quite different emerging in certain regional centres and outer suburban areas: the possibility of two-tier property markets.

It’s a phenomenon we’ve seen before, sometimes with costly consequences for buyers. And with interstate investors increasingly looking towards Victoria for value, it’s worth understanding how these markets develop and what the risks might be.

 

What is a two-tier property market?

A two-tier property market occurs when comparable properties sell at significantly different prices, usually because different groups of buyers are operating in the same market.

Typically, local buyers have established what they’re prepared to pay for a particular type of property. Then an external group enters the market, often with greater purchasing power or different expectations of value, and begins paying higher prices.

This creates two levels of pricing for essentially the same properties.

The problem is sustainability. If the higher prices depend on a particular group of buyers remaining active, what happens when they move elsewhere?

When that additional demand disappears, values can fall back towards the levels supported by local purchasers. Anyone who bought at the higher price may find themselves with a property worth considerably less than they paid.

 

Lessons from previous two-tier property markets

The Gold Coast property boom of the 1990s

One of the clearest examples occurred on Queensland’s Gold Coast during the mid-to-late 1990s.

Developers with excess apartment stock partnered with interstate marketing companies to attract investors from Melbourne, Sydney and elsewhere.

Some went to extraordinary lengths, flying prospective purchasers to Queensland, entertaining them and presenting apartments with attractive views and locations as exceptional investment opportunities.

For buyers comparing Gold Coast prices with what they’d pay for a similar property in Melbourne or Sydney, the proposition looked compelling.

But there was a catch. Comparable apartments advertised through local real estate agencies were often available at substantially lower prices.

The interstate marketing campaigns had effectively created a second, higher-priced market. Buyers were paying a premium that wasn’t supported by local demand, leaving them exposed when they eventually needed to sell.

Henry Kaye and the property investment schemes

A similar lesson emerged through the activities of property promoter Henry Kaye in the late 1990s and early 2000s.

I was working as a valuer in Ballarat around that time and remember discussions about Kaye’s investment schemes, which promised participants the opportunity to build substantial wealth through property.

He ran expensive seminars and promoted property investments that, in some cases, were sold at inflated prices.

Wakelin’s Founder, Richard Wakelin and former colleague, the late Paul Nugent have also spoken to me about prospective clients who attended these seminars. Many were so convinced by the strategies being promoted that it was difficult to persuade them to consider alternative approaches.

Kaye’s business collapsed in 2003, following regulatory action over misleading investment claims.

The broader lesson was the danger of allowing persuasive marketing and promises of future growth to substitute for a sound assessment of a property’s underlying value.

The COVID-era regional property boom

More recently, we saw a related phenomenon during the pandemic.

Lockdowns and the expansion of working from home encouraged metropolitan buyers to consider regional locations. In some areas, this influx drove prices well beyond what local purchasers had traditionally been prepared to pay.

It wasn’t a traditional two-tier market because the increase in demand often lifted prices across the broader market, rather than creating two distinct price levels.

But the underlying risk was similar. Prices were being driven by an unusual source of demand that might not last.

As restrictions eased and city life resumed, some buyers reconsidered regional living. In markets where that additional demand receded, prices came under pressure.

It demonstrated how quickly conditions can change when property values become dependent on a temporary shift in buyer behaviour.

 

Are two-tier markets emerging in Victoria?

What’s happening in Ballarat?

Ballarat provides an interesting contemporary example.

I’ve spoken with several local agents who report increasing activity from buyers’ agents based in Queensland and New South Wales.

These agents are purchasing properties according to fairly specific investment criteria. They typically want fully detached houses, relatively modern construction, a certain number of bedrooms and locations within a prescribed distance of the city.

Many of these properties are in newer housing estates around Ballarat’s outskirts.

What’s particularly interesting is that some purchases are being made sight unseen, not only by the investor but by their buyers’ agent as well. The property appears to meet the required criteria, and that’s enough to proceed.

There’s certainly local demand for these homes. But according to the agents I’ve spoken with, local buyers aren’t necessarily prepared to pay the same prices as these interstate purchasers.

That’s where the possibility of a two-tier market starts to emerge.

The concern is what happens when those buyers’ agents identify another regional centre offering what they consider better opportunities.

If they redirect their clients elsewhere, the additional demand supporting those higher prices could disappear. Investors who purchased at a premium may then struggle to recover their purchase price when selling into the local market.

We’re hearing similar accounts from some outer suburban areas of Melbourne, which is increasingly viewed as representing good value compared with other Australian capitals.

These are early observations rather than evidence of a widespread two-tier market. But they’re developments worth watching.

 

The difference between finding value and creating a market

There’s an important distinction here.

Looking beyond your own city to identify well-priced investment properties is a perfectly legitimate strategy. Good research can uncover opportunities in markets that other buyers may have overlooked.

The concern arises when the activity of outside purchasers begins driving prices beyond what the underlying market can sustain.

If a large group of investors follows the same formula, targets similar properties and competes for a relatively small pool of stock, they can effectively create the price growth they’re seeking.

But that doesn’t necessarily mean the properties have become more valuable in a sustainable sense.

For buyers, the critical question is whether the price is supported by genuine, ongoing demand.

Look at comparable local sales, the depth of the buyer market, rental demand and the potential for additional housing supply. Consider whether the property would attract purchasers at a similar price without the involvement of interstate investment groups.

And if you’re relying on a buyers’ agent, make sure their assessment reflects a genuine understanding of the local market rather than simply whether a property meets a predetermined set of criteria.

 

Take home message

Two-tier property markets aren’t new, and history shows how damaging they can be for buyers who pay prices that aren’t supported by underlying demand.

The reports we’re hearing from Ballarat and parts of Melbourne don’t necessarily mean these markets have become unsustainable. But they do highlight the importance of understanding who’s buying, what they’re paying and why.

There’s nothing wrong with seeking value in unfamiliar markets. The risk comes when buyers confuse a temporary surge in demand with sustainable property growth.

Ultimately, a sound investment needs to stand on its own merits. Make sure the price you’re paying reflects the property’s long-term value, not simply what another group of buyers is prepared to offer today.

Listen to Jarrod’s podcast:

keyboard_arrow_up
Copy link